We were both very excited to try this burger a few weeks back when we heard that Bobby's Burger Place, a fast food joint by Bobby Flay, would carry the burger, but mildly disgusted when we found out BBP's version was lacking a key ingredient--garlic bread! That's what makes this burger unique (we thought!). Finally, last night we decided to make the Mulberry Street Burger ourselves. I should first point out that we were trying to be healthy, so we used ground turkey instead of ground beef (sacrificing flavor, I know, but heart attacks are bad). We halved the amount of crushed red pepper flakes since I don't like too much heat in my food (Megan can handle more).
The end result was good, but not as mind-altering as we had hoped. The mozzarella worked wonderfully, but even with the reduced red pepper flakes, I thought there was a bit too much heat. The garlic ketchup was fantastic and we admittedly dipped our accompanying tator tots in it (and the burger). I would gladly eat a burger swimming in the ketchup! The biggest surprise of all, though, was the garlic bread--I thought it was overkill and I didn't really taste it in the burger. The ketchup and arugula are already such strong flavors that the garlic bread is unnecessary fat, honestly. My recommendation (and what I think we will try next) is to continue stuffing the burger with mozzarella, but instead of the copious red pepper flakes, actually flavor the meat with some hot sauce, maybe some Worcestershire sauce, and some onion for texture. The unflavored meat that the recipe calls for is not very inspiring; I'll go to McDonalds if I want bland burgers. If you do decide to flavor the burger, too, it might be apropos to remove the red pepper flakes from the arugula unless you want your mouth to be on fire. Keep the ketchup--it's fantastic! Make extra for the side. Finally, skip the garlic bread. A nice bakery roll would work better, I think.
We'll let you know how our burger adventures continue. Next update will likely be based upon wherever we eat this weekend (haven't decided yet...Mexican???).